Georgia Tech Cluster Beam Lab
PI: Walt de Heer

research instruments projects publications people collaborators

Recent Projects (2003 - Present)

Electric Dipole Moments and Cluster Metallicity

Lei Ma, Ramiro Moro, Baiqian Zhang, Ilia Larkin, John Indergaard, Walt de Heer
John Bowlan, Anthony Liang, Walt de Heer

One of the most basic properties of a metal is the screening of electric fields. A metal will not tolerate a voltage difference.The charges in metals are delocalized and thus free to move until they reach a configuration where the internal electric field is exactly zero. This is in fact the definition of a metal that is given in introductory electromagnetism. An insulator by contrast is a material where the electrons and ions are bound to a specific location by chemical bonds and their motion throughout the body of a solid is blocked.

We performed electric deflection experiments on free clusters made from over 20 elements (Na, Al, V, Mn, Fe, Co, In, Nb, Mo, Ru, Rh, Pd, Ta, W, Au, Y, Pr, Tb Ho, Tm, and Bi) in a search for electric dipole moments. An electric dipole moment implies that charges are seperated inside a cluster and thus there must exist large internal electric fields. The presence of a dipole moment implies a loss of metallicity.

A molecular beam electric deflection experiment is an extremely robust test for the presence of a dipole moment. The deflection experiments were performed at a temperature of 15-20 K which ensures that the overwhelming majority of the clusters in the beam are in their vibrational ground state. A polar cluster with a permanent dipole moment will rapidly precess inside of the electric deflection field and the beam will be defocused or broadened. This broadening of the beam in deflection is the signiture of a permanent electric dipole moment, and allows for an order of magnitude estimate of the size of the moment. (A precision measurement of the dipole moment requires a priori structural information and must be extracted by comparison with molecular dynamics simulations)

This study is also interesting because it emphasizes just how unusual the ferroelectric state found in V, Nb, and Ta clusters is.






Shell Structure and Polarizabilities of Free Na Clusters

Anthony Liang, John Bowlan, Walt de Heer

The Highest Precision and Most comprehensive measurement of the electric polarizability of the Na clusters to date. We observed large oscillations in the polarizability per atom which correlate with the closing of electronic shells. The amplitude of the oscillations cannot be explained by Jahn-Teller distortions alone.

It is also interesting to note that quantum chemical calculations have predicted electric dipole moments for Na clusters that were in some cases an order of magnitude larger than the values measured by this experiment. This suggests that the calculation of the EDM requires delicate care.










Cluster Beam Electron Spin Resonance

Lei Ma, Ramiro Moro, John Indergaard, Walt de Heer
John Bowlan, Walt de Heer

Many free clusters are either ferromagnetic or paramagnetic and have nonzero total spin. This spin will will precess when placed into an external magnetic field. The frequency of this precessional motion depends on the total spin and the strength of the magnetic field. If we excite the precessing spin with microwave radiation at this frequency then the orientation of the spin will be changed. These "Rabi oscillations" can be detected by molecular beam deflection experiments. We direct a beam of clusters through a series of three magnets. The first inhomogenous Stern-Gerlach magnet (A) deflects the clusters, defocusing the beam. The (C) field is spatially homogenous and contains a high-Q microwave resonator. If strength of C field is tuned so that the cluster's spin precesses at the cavity's resonant frequency then the cluster's spin will be reversed. The third Stern-Gerlach magnet (B) is identical to the first. The fraction of clusters that were resonantly excited by the (C) field are refocused while the rest of the clusters are deflected out of the beam.

In a cluster, the spin is not completely uncoupled. The spin-orbit and hyperfine interactions couple the spin to the cluster body, as well as to the rotations and nuclear spin moments. Each of these couplings will split the resonances and slightly shift their frequencies. These frequency shifts can be measured to extremely high precision. It is reasonable to expect that the shifts can be determined to 1 part per million. This should be compared with the present level of precision in cluster experiments which is seldom better than 1 percent! It should also be noted that this is among the most sensitive detection schemes ever invented - a molecular beam ESR spectrometer is capable of detecting the flipping of a single quantum spin. This represents an energy change on the order of a few meV!

It is also important to note that this type of molecular beam experiment provided some of the first precision tests of quantum mechanics in the 1920s at I.I. Rabi's legendary laboratory at Columbia University. This work was extended by Ramsey and others and has evolved into todays atomic clock technology.






Magnetism of Rare Earth Clusters

John Bowlan, Chris van Dijk, Anthony Liang, Andrei Kirilyuk, Theo Rasing, Walt de Heer

We present molecular beam measurements of ferromagnetic rare-earth clusters, (TbN , HoN and TmN , N < 40) at temperatures from 15 - 200 K. Tb and Ho clusters have total moments smaller than bulk, and the moments are strongly coupled to the cluster framework for most sizes, with several notable exceptions as previously observed for Gd, Dy and Tb clusters. The magnetic moments for Tm clusters increase slightly with increasing temperature, reflecting related bulk behavior. Ferroelectric behavior is found in some Tm clusters, which could have large effects on the indirect exchange. The relatively small magnetic moments indicate partial cancellation of the total spin similar to what occurs, for example, in a ferrimagnetic system.






Multiferroic Cluster Systems

Lei Ma, Ramiro Moro, Baiqian Zhang, Ilia Larkin, John Indergaard, Walt de Heer
John Bowlan, Andrei Kirilyuk, Anthony Liang, Walt de Heer

Electric and magnetic deflection experiments have allowed us to identify several cluster systems that have simultaneous magnetic and electric dipole moments. This implies that they are multiferroic. Multiferroicity is a property which has attracted lots of recent attention due to the possibility of using voltages to manipulate the magnetization in a magnetic recording device. This represents the first discussion of this possibility in a cluster system. We focus our study by considering the case of Rh clusters. Rh is already well known as an example of a system which non magnetic in the bulk but ferromagnetic as a cluster. We report comprehensive measurements of both the magnetic and electric dipole moments. Several rare earth cluster species also have permanent polarizations and magnetizations. In the future it will be necessary to conduct simultaneous electric and magnetic deflection experiments to search for magneto-electric polarizabilities which could couple the magnetization to the polarization, through mechanisms other than the rigid-body motion.






Bistability of Free Cobalt, Iron, Nickel, Mangnese and Chrioum Clusters

Lei Ma, Ramiro Moro, Baiqian Zhang, Ilia Larkin, John Indergaard, Walt de Heer
Xiaoshan Xu, Shuangye Yin, Ramiro Moro, Anthony Liang, John Bowlan, Walt de Heer

Cobalt and iron clusters CoN, FeN (20 < N < 150) measured in a cryogenic molecular beam are found to be bistable with magnetic moments per atom both µN/N~2µB in the ground states and µN*/N~µB in the metastable excited states (for iron clusters, µN ~3NµB and µN* ~NµB). This energy gap between the two states vanish for large clusters, which explains the rapid convergence of the magnetic moments to the bulk value and suggests that ground state for the bulk involves a superposition of the two, in line with the fluctuating local orders in the bulk itinerant ferromagnetism.






Electron Pairing in Ferroelectric Niobium and Niobium Alloy Clusters

Shuangye Yin, Xiaoshan Xu, Ramiro Moro, Anthony Liang, John Bowlan, Walt de Heer

Cryogenic molecular beam experiments show that the ferroelectric dipole moments of small niobium clusters with an even number of valence electrons n are typically greater than those with odd n. This is verified in alloy clusters NbNXM where X=Al, Au, O, Mn, Fe, and Co; N<100;M<3. Like in superconducting alloys, Mn doping quenches the effect while Al and Au enhance it, suggesting a relation between cluster ferroelectricity and bulk superconductivity. A correlated ground state is proposed where the even-odd effect is caused by the depolarizing effect of a single unpaired electron.






Magnetic Enhancement in Cobalt-Manganese Alloy Clusters

Lei Ma, Ramiro Moro, Baiqian Zhang, Ilia Larkin, John Indergaard, Walt de Heer
Shuangye Yin, Ramiro Moro, Xiaoshan Xu, Walt de Heer

Magnetic moments of CoNMnM and CoNVM clusters (N<=60; M<=N/3) are measured in molecular beams using the Stern-Gerlach deflection method. Surprisingly, the per atom average moments of CoNMnM clusters are found to increase with Mn concentration, in contrast to bulk CoMn. The enhancement with Mn doping is found to be independent of cluster size and composition in the size range studied. Meanwhile, CoNVM clusters show reduction of average moments with increasing V doping, consistent with what is expected in bulk CoV. The results are discussed within the virtual bound states model.












Adiabadic Magnetization in Free Cobalt Clusters

Xiaoshan Xu, Shuangye Yin, Ramiro Moro, Walt de Heer

The Langevin-Debye Susceptibility formula holds for a cold cluster adiabatically entering a magnetic field despite the lack of a heat bath to thermalize the orientation of the spin. This is a consequence of the dense nest of a avoided level crossings in the Zeeman diagram of the cluster.



Magnetizations and magnetic moments of free cobalt clusters CoN (12 < N < 200) in a cryogenic (25K - 100K) molecular beam were determined from Stern-Gerlach deflections. All clusters preferentially deflect in the direction of the increasing field and the average magnetization resembles the Langevin function for all cluster sizes even at low temperatures. We demonstrate in the avoided crossing model that the average magnetization may result from adiabatic processes of rotating and vibrating clusters in the magnetic field and that spin relaxation is not involved. This resolves a long-standing problem in the interpretation of cluster beam deflection experiments with implications for nanomagnetic systems in general.






Ferroelectricity in Free Niobium Clusters

Ramiro Moro, Xiaoshan Xu, Shuangye Yin, Walt de Heer

At low temperatures Nb, V, and Ta clusters acquire large electric dipole moments. The deflection profiles are highly asymmetric suggesting that the ferroelectric polarization is weakly coupled to the cluster body. The ferroelectric fraction of the beam declines at temperatures ~40 K. Laser heating experiments which add only one quantum of angular momentum but raise the temperature of the cluster by a huge factor demonstrate the the vanishing of the dipole moment at high temperatures is not an artifact of the rotational motion of the cluster.

The most revealing effect of all is the strong odd-even alternation of the ferroelectric fraction which begins around N = 20, and persists consistently until N = 100. The even-N clusters show a larger ferroelectric fraction than the odd-N clusters. This odd-even alternation depends only on total number of valence electrons in the cluster. The electronic origin of this effect has been demonstrated by a series of experiments where Nb clusters were doped with an impurity - impurities which donate or oxidize an odd number of valence electrons invert the odd-even effect, while impurities such as oxygen which oxidize an even number of valence electrons leave the odd even effect unaffected. Doping a cluster with a magnetic impurity like manganese quenches the dipole moment. (although Co does not appear to destroy the ferroelectricity).

Another notable effect associated with the ferroelectricity is the uncoupling of the electron spin. A double electric and magnetic deflection experiment demonstrates that the ferroelectric clusters with an odd number of electrons have a spin that is completely uncoupled from the cluster body. The spin is coupled to the rotations and cluster body through the spin-orbit interaction, so this effect implies an inhibition of spin-orbit coupling. A state selection experiment where the ferroelectric fraction is removed from the beam by an electric deflection plate demonstrates that the non-ferroelectric clusters have a strongly coupled spin.


Copyright © 2013 W.A. de Heer